Your Guide to Evaluating the New Kids on the Block🆕

In partnership with

Today, we’re examining a fascinating aspect of ETF investing: newly issued ETFs. Picture this: you’re browsing your investment app, and a shiny new ETF catches your eye. It promises exposure to an exciting theme, has low fees, and seems perfect. But how do you evaluate it without years of performance data? It’s like judging a recently opened restaurant based only on its menu. Let’s explore how to assess these newcomers and see if they deserve a spot in your portfolio!

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the easiest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

Sign up to start learning.

🕵️‍♂️Your New ETF Analysis Toolkit

Before we dive into our checklist, it’s important to note that analysing new ETFs requires a different approach than established ones. With older ETFs, you can rely on performance charts and dividend histories, whereas new ETFs force you to make educated guesses about future performance based on current fundamentals.

• 🏅The Management Team's Track Record: While a new ETF may seem unfamiliar, the team behind it often has experience. Research the fund company and their previous products to gauge their success. Major firms, such as Vanguard or BlackRock (iShares), can be assessed based on their track record, but don’t dismiss smaller firms, as they may offer innovative solutions and competitive pricing.

• 🧩Index Methodology and Underlying Strategy: Since historical performance isn't a reliable indicator, it's important to grasp the ETF's objectives and strategy. If it tracks an index, consider these key points:

  • What are the criteria for selecting holdings?

  • How often is the index rebalanced?

  • Are there limits on individual holdings or sectors?

  • How are corporate actions like mergers or spin-offs handled?

  If it's an actively managed ETF, understand the investment strategy, the decision-making process, and the fund managers' investment philosophy. The more transparent and logical the approach, the better you can predict how it might perform in different market conditions.

• 💰Expense Ratio: New ETFs often start with competitive expense ratios to attract investors, but be aware that introductory rates may increase after the first year. Compare similar ETFs and consider the complexity of the strategy. Simple index ETFs should have lower fees than complex strategies.

• 💧Liquidity and Market Maker Support: New ETFs often struggle with trading volume, resulting in wider bid-ask spreads that can impact returns. Evaluate the liquidity of underlying holdings, the market makers involved, and the fund company’s commitment to supporting liquidity.

• 🔄Market Timing and Economic Environment: Assess whether you’re evaluating the ETF at the right time. For example, an emerging markets ETF may shine during strong periods but struggle when conditions shift. Consider potential performance across different economic cycles.

• 🥊Competitive Landscape Analysis: Analyse the competition even if a new ETF seems unique. Consider existing options and how this ETF differentiates itself—whether through lower fees, more effective methodologies, or enhanced liquidity. Remember, newer isn’t always better, but innovation can bring real improvements.

Analysing new ETFs is part art, part science. You're betting on the fund company's ability to execute its strategy effectively while simultaneously judging whether that strategy makes sense for your portfolio. The key is finding the sweet spot between being open to innovation and maintaining a healthy scepticism. Some of today's most successful ETFs were once "new and unproven," but plenty of others have quietly disappeared into the ETF graveyard.

Red Flags🚩and Action Plan📃

While we're focusing on the positives, let's quickly cover some warning signs:

• ❌Unclear or overly complex strategies that are difficult to understand

• ❌Extremely narrow themes that might be fads

• ❌Significantly higher fees than comparable existing options without clear justification

• ❌Unknown fund companies with no track record in ETF management

• ❌Timing that seems too convenient (launching right at the peak of a trend)

When you find a promising new ETF, consider starting with a small position after it meets your analysis criteria. This approach allows you to take advantage of potential gains while minimising your risk. As the ETF develops a track record and proves its worth, you can gradually increase your investment.

Remember, there's no rush. Unlike limited-time sales at your favourite store, ETFs don't vanish overnight. If a new ETF genuinely provides value, it will likely still be available—and possibly even improved—in six months or a year, when you have more data to evaluate.

💡The Art of Judging a Book by Its Cover

Analysing newly issued ETFs may seem daunting at first. Still, armed with the right tools and knowledge, you can make informed decisions even when historical performance data is limited or unavailable. Focus on the fundamentals: understand the strategy, evaluate the team, assess the competitive landscape, and consider the timing.

The most important takeaway? Don't let the excitement of something new cloud your judgment, but also don't dismiss innovation out of hand. The ETF industry thrives on providing investors with better, cheaper, and more targeted investment options; sometimes, the new kid on the block does bring something special to the table.

We hope you've enjoyed this deep dive into the world of new ETF analysis! The ETF universe is constantly evolving, bringing new opportunities and challenges; we're here to help you navigate them all. Join the ETF UNO community for exclusive insights, detailed analysis, and valuable discussions with fellow investors. Together, we're building a smarter, more informed approach to ETF investing – one newsletter at a time!

DISCLAIMER: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research and consider consulting with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.