🌱Sustainable Investing Made Simple: The iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF (ESGU) Deep Dive

In partnership with

Today, we’re examining the iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF $ESGU ( ▲ 0.44% ) , one of the largest and most established ESG-focused ETFs in the market. Launched in December 2016 by BlackRock’s iShares, ESGU has accumulated over $13 billion in assets under management (AUM). But does its size guarantee better performance? More importantly, should ESGU be included in your portfolio? Let’s find out.

Stay up-to-date with AI

The Rundown is the most trusted AI newsletter in the world, with 1,000,000+ readers and exclusive interviews with AI leaders like Mark Zuckerberg, Demis Hassibis, Mustafa Suleyman, and more.

Their expert research team spends all day learning what’s new in AI and talking with industry experts, then distills the most important developments into one free email every morning.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

Sign up to start learning.

What is ESGU?

ESGU provides exposure to large- and mid-cap U.S. stocks with strong environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings. It seeks to match the risk and return of the MSCI USA Index while promoting sustainability.

The fund tracks the MSCI USA Extended ESG Focus Index, using a methodology that balances ESG factors with market exposure. Instead of excluding entire sectors, ESGU optimises its holdings by favouring companies with solid ESG profiles, maintaining similar risk characteristics to the traditional MSCI USA Index.

Within iShares' own ESG lineup, ESGU faces competition from the newer iShares ESG MSCI USA Leaders ETF (SUSL), launched in May 2019. Here's how they stack up:

• 💰Expense Ratios: SUSL has a 0.10% expense ratio, which is lower than ESGU's 0.15% expense ratio. This 5-basis-point difference might seem minimal, but it compounds over time.

• 📊Index Methodology: While ESGU tracks the MSCI USA Extended ESG Focus Index (optimisation approach), SUSL follows the MSCI USA Extended ESG Leaders Index, which takes a more concentrated approach by focusing on industry leaders in ESG practices.

• 🔄Performance Correlation: The correlation between SUSL and ESGU is 0.96, which is considered to be high. This suggests that, despite their different approaches, both funds exhibit remarkably similar patterns.

• 🌊Risk Profile: Notably, SUSL exhibits higher volatility compared to ESGU. ESGU's optimisation approach delivers slightly smoother returns.

• 🏦 Asset Size: ESGU's substantially larger asset base provides better liquidity and potentially lower tracking error, both crucial factors for institutional investors.

Investment Strategy📊

There are various approaches to positioning ESGU in your ETF portfolio.

• 🗻Core Holding Strategy: ESGU works exceptionally well as a core equity holding in portfolios seeking ESG exposure without dramatically altering risk characteristics. Given its broad diversification across 280+ holdings and its optimisation methodology, ESGU can replace traditional large-cap core funds while adding sustainable investment criteria.

• 🛰️Satellite Strategy: For investors already holding broad market ETFs like SPY or VTI, ESGU can serve as a satellite holding, representing 15-25% of their U.S. equity allocation. This approach enables you to maintain traditional market exposure while gradually incorporating ESG considerations.

• 📈ESG Portfolio Construction: In a fully ESG-focused portfolio, ESGU serves as the U.S. large-cap foundation, complemented by:

  • International ESG exposure

  • Small-cap ESG exposure

  • ESG bond allocation

ESGU at a glance

ETF Issuer: iShares

Inception: 2016-12-01

Asset Class: Equity

Underlying Index: MSCI USA Extended ESG Focus Index

Geographical Focus: U.S.

Expense Ratio: 0.15% (as of last data point)

Dividend Yield: 1.16% (as of last data point)

Distribution Frequency: Quarterly

Historical Performance

ESGU has achieved a return of 7.3% over the past year, 7.9% over the last three years, and 17.8% annually over the past five years. While these returns place ESGU in the middle of its peer group, the fund's five-year annualised return of 17.8% highlights its ability to capture long-term market growth while adhering to ESG criteria.

ETF Radar View

The radar chart below shows the general characteristics of the ETF:

Top 3 Reasons to Invest

1. Institutional-Grade ESG Implementation: ESGU's optimisation methodology represents one of the most sophisticated approaches to ESG integration available in the ETF market. Rather than simply excluding companies or sectors, the fund uses quantitative models to overweight ESG leaders while maintaining broad market characteristics. This approach appeals to institutional investors seeking ESG exposure while adhering to modern portfolio theory principles.

2. Cost-Effective Sustainable Exposure: With a 0.15% expense ratio, ESGU provides cost-effective access to professionally managed ESG screening. While not the cheapest ESG option available, the fee structure remains competitive for the level of analysis and optimisation provided.

3. Liquidity and Scale Advantages: ESGU's substantial assets of $13 billion provide excellent liquidity for both retail and institutional investors. Recent fund flows indicate sustained investor interest despite some outflows over extended periods.

Top 3 Reasons Not to Invest

1. Performance Drag During Value Rotations: ESG funds, including ESGU, typically underweight traditional value sectors, such as energy and financials. During periods when these sectors outperform—as seen in various cycles—ESGU may lag broader market indices. The recent year-to-date underperformance of -5.1% versus the category average illustrates this challenge.

2. ESG Criteria Subjectivity: ESG ratings are inherently subjective and can fluctuate over time. Companies with strong ESG scores today may face controversies tomorrow, and the fund's optimisation approach means it may not immediately react to ESG developments. Additionally, some investors may disagree with MSCI's ESG methodology or scoring criteria.

3. Concentration Risk in Growth Sectors: ESGU's ESG optimisation tends to overweight technology and healthcare while underweighting energy and materials. This creates an implicit growth tilt that may not be suitable for all market environments or investor preferences. During periods favouring value stocks or cyclical sectors, this bias becomes a performance headwind.

Inside the $13 Billion ESG ETF Giant⚖️

ESGU offers a solid approach to sustainable investing, balancing ESG considerations with practical portfolio management. Its efficient methodology, reasonable costs, and institutional-quality execution make it appealing for investors seeking ESG exposure alongside traditional market returns.

While ESGU faces challenges, the importance of ESG factors in long-term investment success is growing. It suits investors looking for a "set it and forget it" ESG core holding or those building sustainable portfolios. However, those focused solely on maximising returns may find better value in traditional broad market funds.

Ready to explore ETF analysis and investment opportunities? Join our ETF UNO community for exclusive insights, portfolio strategies, and real-time market analysis. Whether you’re building your first ESG allocation or refining a multi-ETF portfolio, we provide the tools you need to invest confidently. Subscribe now to access our latest ETF research and market commentary!

DISCLAIMER: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice. Always conduct your own research and consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.