🎯ETF Showdown: How to Compare Funds Like a Pro

In partnership with

Welcome back to ETF101, fellow investors! Today, we’re focusing on a vital skill for ETF investors: comparison. Whether choosing between similar index-based ETFs or selecting the right sector fund, effective ETF comparison can significantly impact your returns.

Think of it like shopping for a car—you wouldn’t just pick the first one you see. You’d consider factors like gas mileage and safety ratings. Similarly, we must look beyond the surface when comparing ETFs to understand their true value.

Get Over $6K of Notion Free with Unlimited AI

Startups move fast. That's why thousands of startups worldwide trust Notion as their connected, customizable workspace. In one place, you can organize, plan, and execute—whether you're managing investor outreach, documenting key decisions, or scaling operations.

Apply now to get up to 6 months of Notion with unlimited AI free, a $6,000+ value. Access AI's limitless potential right inside Notion and build your company with one powerful tool.

Get Unlimited Notion AI Now

Why ETF Comparison Matters More Than You Think?🤔

Before we dive into the details, let's address a common misconception: "Can't I just choose the cheapest ETF that tracks my target index?" While low fees are certainly important, many other factors must be considered. Two ETFs may track the same index but can still perform very differently due to liquidity, tracking accuracy, and dividend payment handling.

We've witnessed too many investors get burned by selecting an ETF based solely on its expense ratio, only to find that their "cheap" fund consistently underperformed its benchmark. Let's ensure you avoid making the same mistake.

📃Key Factors for Comparing ETFs

Let's break down the essential factors you should consider when comparing ETFs. Think of these as your ETF comparison toolkit:

• 💰Expense Ratio: The expense ratio is akin to a monthly maintenance fee for your investment, expressed as a percentage of the fund's annual charges. For example, a 0.2% expense ratio means you pay $2 for every $1,000 invested. While comparing expense ratios among similar ETFs is important, it shouldn’t be your only consideration. A 0.05% difference may seem small, but it can add up over time. Sometimes, paying a higher ratio for better performance or liquidity is worth it.

• 🎯Tracking Error: Tracking error indicates how closely an ETF's performance aligns with its underlying index, with lower values being preferable. It's important to assess both the average tracking error and its pattern over time. An ETF that occasionally outperforms might have a similar average tracking error to one that consistently underperforms, but the latter is typically more concerning.

• 🔄Liquidity and Trading Volume: Liquidity is the ease of buying or selling ETF shares without affecting their price. A higher average daily volume usually indicates better liquidity. Casual investors should look for ETFs with over 100,000 shares in daily volume, while larger trades benefit from volumes in the millions. Also, narrower bid-ask spreads indicate better liquidity.

• 📦Assets Under Management (AUM): AUM, or Assets Under Management, shows how much money is in an ETF. Larger funds usually provide better liquidity and resources. ETFs with less than $100 million in assets may risk closure, while those over $500 million are generally stable. However, don’t overlook smaller niche ETFs if they fit a specific purpose in your investment strategy.

• 📊Holdings and Sector Exposure: Even ETFs tracking the same index might have slightly different holdings due to sampling strategies or rebalancing timing. Check the top 10 holdings and sector weightings. Look for any significant deviations from the benchmark. Also, consider geographic exposure for international ETFs – some might have more concentration in specific countries than others.

• 💵Dividend Treatment: How an ETF handles dividends can significantly impact your after-tax returns. Understand whether the ETF distributes dividends or reinvests them automatically. Also, the dividend tax treatment should be checked, especially for international ETFs where foreign tax credits come into play.

• 🏢Fund Management and Provider: The company behind the ETF matters more than you might think. Research the fund provider's track record, especially for newer or more specialised ETFs. Established providers like Vanguard, BlackRock (iShares), and State Street have extensive experience but don't overlook quality offerings from smaller providers.

• 🧾Tax Efficiency: Nobody likes paying unnecessary taxes. Look at the ETF's turnover ratio (lower is generally better for tax efficiency) and its history of capital gains distributions. In taxable accounts, tax efficiency can significantly impact your net returns.

Here are some of the best tools to simplify your comparison process. In our previous article, we discussed useful resources for comparing ETFs, including ETF.com and VettaFi. If you're already logged into your brokerage account, it's convenient to use their built-in ETF comparison tools, as they can display your specific costs and any commission-free offerings. Additionally, if you have technical skills, creating your own comparison spreadsheet can be beneficial. This allows you to incorporate your unique tax situation and investment goals.

🛣️Your ETF Comparison Journey

Comparing ETFs might seem overwhelming initially, but it becomes easier with practice, just like any other skill. Keep these key points in mind:

• Look beyond the expense ratio.

• Use multiple tools for a comprehensive analysis.

• Consider your specific investment goals and timeline.

• Don’t overlook tax implications.

• Remember that practice makes perfect.

The advantage of ETF investing is that once you master these comparison skills, you can create a sophisticated portfolio tailored to your needs and goals. Strong comparison skills are essential to your foundation, whether you’re building a core-satellite portfolio, implementing factor investing strategies, or exploring niche sectors.

We hope this deep dive into ETF comparison has been valuable for your investment journey. Remember, the ETF UNO community is here to support you every step of the way. Join our growing newsletter of ETF enthusiasts, where we regularly share insights, analysis, and real-time discussions about market trends and opportunities.

Happy investing, and see you in the next ETF101 lesson!

DISCLAIMER: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research and consider consulting with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.